premium sandwiches × Crafted with Love


We are your purveyor of classic deli fare with a twist.


During a visit to the east coast, we were impressed by the plethora of family-run delicatessens and sandwich shops, especially those of New York.  Fresh sliced, high quality meats and cheeses piled high on great bread was the norm.  Upon the return home, the disparity of good sandwiches became apparent.  So we set out to recreate what we had experienced in those East Coast delis while working in some of our own heritage and family recipes.  In 2004, New York Deli opened its doors.  Over a decade later, the menu has grown to include the classic deli sandwiches, toasted sub sandwiches, paninis, wraps, salads, and soups.  While constantly evolving, New York Deli continues to be the quintessential deli in northeast Wisconsin.




(920) 734-3354


(920) 734-6363


1853 N. Casaloma Dr.

Appleton, WI  54913



M-F 10p–7p
Sa-Su 10–3p

At New York Deli, the best sandwiches start with the best meats and cheeses...

Boar’s Head Brand® began in the New York City area in 1905. Products were delivered by horse-drawn wagon to small delicatessens and “Mom and Pop” stores.

By 1933, distribution of Boar’s Head Brand products had grown. It was at that time that our founder, Frank Brunckhorst, dissatisfied with the quality of cooked hams which were available to him, decided that he would open a manufacturing plant of his own. The first plant was started in a small building in Brooklyn with only three employees.

Even back then there were thousands of delicatessens in New York City, and there were a great number of small manufacturers of delicatessen specialties. The competition among these manufacturers was keen; and as a result, very high standards were set for the quality of delicatessen products. Frank Brunckhorst set his own high standards, and he would not vary from them. Before long, our products could be found in all of the best delicatessens, gourmet stores and fine food establishments in the New York City area.

Over the years since that time, most other manufacturers of delicatessen products have made compromises in quality for the sake of convenience and economy. But Boar’s Head has never done so. To this day, five generations later, descendants of the Brunckhorst family still insist on the same unwavering commitment to high standards set by Frank long ago.

New York Deli is proud to serve the BoarsHead Brand of deli meats, cheeses, and condiments.  Stop in and check out our deli case for a wide variety of the most palate pleasing deli products available.  All deli orders are cut to order.  For added convenience, call ahead your order at (920) 734-3354.

Contact Us!

If you have any questions, comments, or concerns, please don't hesitate to drop a line.  If its something that needs immediate attention, please give us a call.  We hope you've enjoyed your experience with New York Deli.  If you wish to place an order, please call the shop at (920) 734-3354 or fax us at (920) 734-6363.

Name *