We are your purveyor of classic deli fare with a twist.


During a visit to the east coast, we were impressed by the plethora of family-run delicatessens and sandwich shops, especially those of New York.  Fresh sliced, high quality meats and cheeses piled high on great bread was the norm.  Upon the return home, the disparity of good sandwiches became apparent.  So we set out to recreate what we had experienced in those East Coast delis while working in some of our own heritage and family recipes.  In 2004, New York Deli opened its doors.  Over a decade later, the menu has grown to include the classic deli sandwiches, toasted sub sandwiches, paninis, wraps, salads, and soups.  While constantly evolving, New York Deli continues to be the quintessential deli in northeast Wisconsin.




(920) 734-3354


(920) 734-6363


1853 N. Casaloma Dr.

Appleton, WI  54913



(October through March)

DAILY 10a–3p